Hospitals Ranked by HCAHPS Score

Share this post

The Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) is a patient satisfaction survey required by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) for all hospitals in the United States. It is administered to a random sample of adult patients across medical conditions between 48 hours and 6 weeks after discharge.

In CMS' HCAHPS survey, patients provide feedback on their hospital experience, including:

Communication with nurses  
Communication with doctors  
Responsiveness when help is required  
Pain management  
Communication about medicines
 Discharge information  
Cleanliness and quietness of hospital environment  
Overall Hospital rating

The survey results are publicly reported for all to see and may impact a healthcare organization’s reputation. Additionally, the government provides reimbursement based on results. Within a value-based care environment, in particular, excellent survey performance keeps the hospital financially strong.

Definitive Healthcare's Hospitals & IDNs platform provides a 360-degree view of more than 8,800 U.S. hospitals and IDNs. Users can access intelligence on merger and acquisition activity, software and technology implementations, affiliations, and detailed financial, clinical, and quality metrics like HCAHPS scores.

According to Definitive Healthcare, only 218 U.S. hospitals had an overall five-star rating in 2019 (compared to 233 in 2018), and 94 had a one-star rating (compared to 67 in 2018). Here are the U.S. hospitals with the highest and lowest HCAHPS ratings:

10 Hospitals with 5 HCAHPS Stars by Net Patient Revenue

Rank	Hospital Name	Definitive ID	Net Patient Revenue	Discharges
1.	Mayo Clinic Hospital - Arizona	178	$1,482,962,722	16,363
2.	The James Cancer Hospital and Solove Research Institute	3138	$1,286,815,831	15,193
3.	Dana Farber Cancer Institute	1978	$1,130,077,403	1,304
4.	Seattle Cancer Care Alliance	5692	$698,053,511	560
5.	Fox Chase Cancer Center	3560	$407,706,933	3,814
6.	Oklahoma Heart Hospital North	3331	$318,307,636	8,550
7.	New England Baptist Hospital	1971	$225,021,802	8,563
8.	Arkansas Heart Hospital	275	$197,802,616	6,194
9.	Parkview Ortho Hospital	1287	$186,055,048	2,962
10.	South County Hospital	3611	$176,746,358	5,804

Fig 1 .Data from Definitive Healthcare’s Hospitals & IDNs platform, sourced from hospital self-reporting to CMS in CY 2019.

The above table features the U.S.' top rated hospitals in terms of HCAHPS scores. This list includes a smattering of smaller hospitals, and a high volume of specialized hospitals—particularly cancer centers.

Cancer centers may receive higher ratings because they are highly specialized, and report lower patient volumes, which may result in a better patient experience. It is interesting to note that nearly all of these hospitals are classified as short-term acute care hospitals: facilities where patients tend to visit their trusted primary care provider, with whom they build and foster relationships. 

10 Hospitals with 1 HCAHPS Star by Net Patient Revenue

Rank	Hospital Name	Definitive ID	Net Patient Revenue	Discharges
1.	NYC Health and Hospitals - Kings County	2806	$1,348,496,304	16,077
2.	Westchester Medical Center	2926	$1,233,480,843	23,283
3.	Maimonides Medical Center	2803	$993,247,127	34,994
4.	Staten Island University Hospital - North Campus	2886	$934,818,061	36,635
5.	BronxCare Hospital Center - Fulton Campus	2757	$690,478,090	27,254
6.	The University Hospital	2663	$685,143,132	15,230
7.	University Medical Center of Southern Nevada	2585	$682,222,696	25,789
8.	NYC Health and Hospitals - Jacobi	2755	$653,301,360	16,900
9.	NYC Health and Hospitals - Elmhurst	2879	$582,347,357	17,680
10.	St Francis Medical Center	377	$527,500,725	19,807

Fig 2. Data from Definitive Healthcare’s Hospitals & IDNs platform, sourced from hospital self-reporting to CMS in CY 2019.

This list represents 10 U.S. hospitals that received a one-star HCAHPS score from CMS. As a whole, these hospitals do have a higher number of discharge volumes than the hospitals with five-star ratings, so these low scores may be a result of higher patient-to-provider ratios and staffing shortages.

Patients already expect quality care and strong communication from their care providers, so a better patient experience may help improve these hospitals' HCAHPS ratings. However, many factors influence patient satisfaction, including noise pollution, high patient volumes, and the number of patients who are non-native English speakers.

Learn more

Definitive Healthcare provides users with an in-depth look into healthcare organization's HCAHPS scores and how they compare to state and national averages.

To learn more about Definitive Healthcare's quality of care data, including HCAHPS scores, readmission and complication rates, and infection measures, visit our blog.

Originally published May 15, 2019