Top 20 DRGs by Highest Readmission Rates

One of the biggest priorities in hospital care today is identifying the risks of and avoiding preventable readmissions. In 2011, readmissions cost the healthcare system $41.3 billion according to one estimate, a figure that has almost certainly increased in recent years. CMS keeps track of readmission rates for all diagnosis-related group (DRG) codes, which define the total reimbursement a hospital receives for any episode of care. The following list contains the top 20 DRG codes by the highest Medicare patient readmission rate with at least 1,000 claims in 2015, excluding chemotherapy, lymphoma, and leukemia, which have uniquely high readmission rates. While they may not include the DRGs with the greatest overall admission costs by volume, they represent the conditions that may experience the highest rate decrease due to a focused readmission prevention effort.

The majority of the top 20 DRG codes involve surgical care, as indicated by “OR Proc” in many of their descriptions. Given the number of potential complications from surgery (infections, medical errors, improper healing or wound reopenings), it’s not surprising the procedures would have higher rates of readmission. There are a few exceptions. Peripheral nerve disorders or neuropathies are commonly associated with other health conditions such as diabetes, especially in elderly populations, and likely contribute to greater readmission rates. Liver conditions also ranked highly, often due to complications of cirrhosis, alcohol hepatitis, or encephalopathy due to loss of function.

The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ Readmission Reduction Program establishes reimbursement penalties for hospitals with excessive preventable readmissions. Penalties can amount to up to a three percent reduction in a hospital’s Medicare reimbursement. Since its launch in 2012, total savings to CMS have totaled about $927 million, not including an estimated $528 million in reimbursement cuts for FY 2017.

The hospitals with the highest estimated revenue losses due to penalties for FY 2017 under the Readmission Reduction Program are shown in the table on the next page. While a hospital’s readmission rate target is determined on an individual basis, all but three of the hospitals had an all-cause readmission rate higher than 15.6 percent, the average rate of all other hospitals that were assessed. Most of the top 20 hospitals also had higher-than-average case mixes, which are associated with more readmissions but are adjusted for in the Readmission Reduction Program.

The number of hospitals penalized under the Readmission Reduction Program has grown steadily from 2012 to 2016, with a significant jump between 2014 and 2015. Starting in 2015, CMS introduced two new readmissions measures for COPD and total joint replacement, which is a likely explanation for the increase. Despite the rising number of penalized hospitals, CMS has credited the program with a nationwide eight percent reduction in readmission rates from 2010 to 2015. A review of the data also shows that 1,722 hospitals, or about half of hospitals in the program, received penalties for all five years. The total number of hospitals receiving the maximum penalty has also increased since 2014, reaching 63 for FY 2017, as seen in the graph below. The number is far below that of 2013, but the original maximum penalty was only a one percent reimbursement cut, growing to two percent in the second year, and was applied to hospitals that would currently face a deeper cut.

Hospitals with Greatest Estimated Readmission Penalties in 2017

Top 20 Hospitals Compared to Others, 2017

Hospitals Given Reimbursement Penalties

Hospitals Given Maximum Reimbursement Penalty